Tuesday, October 6, 2009

Directors Commentary for Green Consumerism Video

Economic Nature-Green Consumerism(http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=hb5GDday7Aw)

Our video subject was based on the topic of economic nature and green consumerism (Infinite Nature Chapter 5, p 87-91). Green consumerism is most commonly visible in our lives when we make an outing to the grocery store. These days within most every chain grocery store you can find a natural/organic section or aisle. We decided to show some insight as to how much going totally “green” in your grocery shopping can cost you compared to similar non-natural/organic products. We not only showed the cost of going green, but we wanted have a discussion as to what buying green really means for individuals as well as the environment.
Overall we felt that non-green products weren’t the problem; over consumption is the main problem. We agree with the point made in lecture that with the growing population and the more wealthy people get, the more we will consume. Consuming more is not necessarily green, even when you using the genuine and disingenuous green products.
The cost of buying green is most certainly on the rise. As mentioned in lecture, people buy green to make them feel less guilty, regardless of the price. In our video we actually go to the grocery store and buy completely organic/natural foods and regular foods. For both the regular and organic products, we mixed name brand and non name brand products to see a close to typical price comparison. People maybe will to pay more to make them feel less guilty and feel as though they are helping save the environment. Although prices are most certainly higher than comparable products they may possibly go down in the future, as since the green revolution is till in its infancy.
There are currently many companies that are apart of the "Go Green movement". As mentioned in lecture, there are different labels like EnergyStar, GreenStar and others that certify green products. The labels "natural" and "organic" are the same. Although "natural" is not a certified term it does have meaning, which is explained in our video. Also, products labeled organic met certain criteria to, for one example produced without the use of pesticides, to obtain the label. With the Go Green movement gaining force, there is a demand for these products. Obviously with a demand, there has to be companies to supply.
Among consumers there is a misconception that buying green products will save our environment. We agree with the point made in lecture that with the growing population and the more wealthy people get, the more we will consume. Consuming more is not necessarily green, even when you using the genuine and disingenuous green products. Although people may feel better about themselves and think they are doing a service to the environment and others, making slightly different shopping decisions won't be the cure all. There has to be a larger scale movement, possibly government policies to regulate.
However, Green products do have an impact, but maybe not as much as they are advertised. One point brought up in our video is, it worth buying five pairs of organic jeans vs. one pair of regular? How much did cost to create organic fibers? A similar advertisement raves that plastic bottled water that uses 15% less plastic. This bottle may less than before but still results in waste. In lecture, the example of the Styrofoam cup vs. ceramic mug is similar.
- Minimize environmental impact:
- Ceramic mug can be recycled, not decompose
- Ceramic mug lasts longer, but has to wash it (water cost)
- Takes more energy to make a mug than a Styrofoam cup
- Have to use ceramic mug a 1000 times to break even.

References Used:
Green Consumerism- Greening All the Way to the Bank (http://sites.google.com/site/richardgosden/green-consumerism)
This article was useful for us to form our opinion that there is little prospect for green consumerism succeeding as a method for solving the environmental crisis.

Buying into the Green Movement
(http://www.nytimes.com/2007/07/01/fashion/01green.html?_r=1&pagewanted=all)
We gained a few very useful quotes and ideas that we used in our video.

USDA Organic- National Organic Plan
(http://www.ams.usda.gov/AMSv1.0/getfile?dDocName=STELDEV3004446&acct=nopgeninfo)
This article from the USDA was imperative to understand what the term organic means and how it is regulated.

Organic Food & Natural Food -what's the difference?
(http://www.naturalhub.com/food_issues_identifying_natural_food.htm)
We found this article to be best to form a definition of what products are considered “natural”.

The (still) high cost of organic food
(http://www.eartheasy.com/article_high_cost_organic_food.htm)
This article brought to our attention the details of why organics still cost more even if there is a demand.

26 comments:

  1. I found your comparison in costs of organic vs. regular products very interesting! I really liked how you guys did side by side comparisons, it was something as a shopper I go through each grocery trip. I do like purchasing organic products, not only for their environmental benefits, but the quality of the goods, but once I get to the check out line it seems to be a different story! Job well done!

    --- Kirsten Dobson

    ReplyDelete
  2. I really liked this video. I thought that it was well thought out and very creative. I really liked your comparison of organic verses regular products. It was good perspective on buying organic, and illustrates why a lot of people choose not to buy green for the very reason of saving money. This video definitely does a good job on demonstrating both the positive and negative aspects of green consumerism. I really enjoyed the music and editing to the video as well, I think it definitely helps to keep the audience entertained and focused on the material.

    ReplyDelete
  3. The video explains the difference between natural and organic definitions. They then go on to purchase the same products as regular, store brand and compare it to organic. Naturally the cost is astronomically higher for the organic cart. They conclude the video by saying that maybe the solution is to buy less instead of buying the same amount except organic. I did like seeing the side-by-side comparison of the various products to see that organic actually does cost more than regular products. This video kept me entertained and made me really consider the possibility that just cutting down on consumption may be the answer.

    ReplyDelete
  4. The presentation of this video is awesome. It was a perfect blend of text, images, and voice overs. All of the information was easy to understand but yet stimulating. The group did a really nice job of complementing the text rather than just repeating it. They showed strong evidence that green consumerism is not enough. We will all have to consume a little less if we want to make a difference.

    ReplyDelete
  5. Great comparisons presented during the video with the side by side prices of carts full of similar items. There was also a lot of good information throughout the video that can be useful to anyone wanting to possibly start shopping more organic or what not. It also does a good job of raising the ones previous thoughts on the matter of shopping regular vs. organic. Overall the video provided both sides of the argument with well thought out information that was conveyed in an easy to follow and understand manner in which you did not lose the attention of the person watching the video.

    ReplyDelete
  6. I enjoyed how the video compared the prices of foods in each cart from organic sources and non- organic sources. Also I enjoyed how the video was fair and balanced and gave the viewer factual evidence for your argement.

    ReplyDelete
  7. I thought you all did an excellent job with this video. I really like the way you conveyed the fact that simply buying "green" is not the answer to our environmental problems. We must buy less to decrease our impact. I also liked the way you showed the viewer the cost differences between buying regular items versus buying organic/natural items. The opening clip of the "natural" beer was a funny introduction to a more serious issue. My only critique is that you could have changed up the speaker for a less monotonous audio. Otherwise, great job!

    ReplyDelete
  8. I liked the commercial that opened the movie. It grabbed my intention and was a good introduction into the video. Also, I really liked the scene where they compared the price of organic and regular foods. It gave me a feel of how much more expensive it really is to buy organic and left me questioning if it was really worth it.

    ReplyDelete
  9. I think that Group 16 did a great job of engaging the audience in the first 30 seconds. After seeing the first scene I wanted to watch the rest of the video to see what other fun and informative content they included. I think the group did a good job of switching between wordage and voiceovers. However, the shaking of the background when the group was at Kroger made it hard to concentrate on the video. It was good that even though the video was about going green that the group included the organic vs. regular food prices. I think this group did a fantastic job representing their portion of Infinite Nature!!

    ReplyDelete
  10. Great video! I loved how they actually went out and shopped to show us the price difference when you buy “natural” and “organic” food and products versus regular items. I also liked how they started with green foods and grocery items and then applied it to clothing as well. Their main point was that just going green is not going to be enough. We all need to consume less overall.

    ReplyDelete
  11. Good Job! I loved the natural beer video in the beginning and how you guys compared organic vs. regular food. I buy organic at home when my mom is paying for it but down here when I'm paying for it myself I find myself buying regular food. You guys did a great job expanding past the food to include clothing.

    ReplyDelete
  12. That was a really good way to show the difference in costs between natural and regular foods. It's eye-opening and just goes to show how much people will pay to feel better about themselves for helping out the environment. By the way, great filming job!

    ReplyDelete
  13. I really liked the video I thought it was very creative and well put together. I like how you focused on the grocery shopping aspect of green consumerism. People can talk about going green but when it comes down to it it's about if you can afford the money out of your pocket. I also like the reference to the jeans and comparing it to the mug/styrofoam cup. You can't just look at the product itself, you have to consider its entire life cycle so green isn't necesarily so perfect. Good job!

    ReplyDelete
  14. This 'Green Consumerism' video was very well put together! I really enjoyed the variety of multimedia that the group used to get the point across. Your idea that we need to start being 'green' by reducing our amount of consumption is great! I also liked that the group was not biased towards organic/natural foods, and the comparison you all did in the supermarket was a very realistic idea of what most of society cannot afford. Great Job!
    -Katie Lively

    ReplyDelete
  15. The cost analysis portion of this video was very effective because it really showed how this decision DIRECTLY affects me. A forty dollar difference in what looked to be one and a half to two weeks of groceries is always going to make me reconsider. The video also raises the point that what we are buying is not nearly as important as the quantities of things we are buying. Overall I thought it was an effective means of getting across their point.

    ReplyDelete
  16. The commercial was a great way to start off the video. Really like the “fast forward” effect while shopping. Music went along well. I did have to go to the actual you tube site to watch the video because it wouldn’t play even though it had loaded on the class site.

    ReplyDelete
  17. You guys had smooth lead in’s and transitions between the different topics covered and the video/voice-over. The music was a great addition as well. I like how you actually went to Kroger and priced out the same groceries, both organic and inorganic. Great idea!

    ReplyDelete
  18. I really enjoyed this video. I felt it explained natural and organic products well and had a rather upbeat pace despite the voice over was rather monotone. This making it easier to clearly understand what he is saying. I like the scene where it showed the price of the regular products compared to the final price of the organic/natural products using the self check out, and that they also gave a solution to consume less rather than just buy more organic products.

    ReplyDelete
  19. The video definitely helped to get across the feeling of confusion that many consumers feel when at the grocery store. The comparison of prices of organic vs. non-“natural” helps people see where the “green” products could be hitting them in the wallet. The message is exactly what consumers need to understand: just buy less!

    ReplyDelete
  20. This comment has been removed by the author.

    ReplyDelete
  21. I really enjoyed this video. I thought the beginning was a very good, creative way to start off you all's video. I also really liked the comparison of the prices for regular products compared to natural/organic products. I believe that helps the audience realize why people don't switch to natural/organic products simply because it would just be too much money. I thought the video flowed very well and provided good information on your topic. Overall, I thought the video was very good.

    -Jacob Evans

    ReplyDelete
  22. Nice video. Great editing job. You all did a great job of highlighting not only natural vs. conventional food issues, but examples like clothing as well. I was really happy to see that you touched on the issue of consumption: buying organic products will not save the world, we need to cut down on what we consume overall. I would have liked to see a little more detail about the different specifics of organic food and what the terms actually mean.

    ReplyDelete
  23. Great job filming, I really liked the first clip, it went along well with the points on misconception on what’s “natural.” Really liked the idea of taking the filming into the grocery store, instead of just talking about what you found in the store. I also liked the closing remarks on it may be smarter to just buy less, instead of buying a lot of “earth-friendly” items. The only thing that I think took away from the video was the shakiness of the camera from speeding up the film during the production. But other than that, great job.

    ReplyDelete
  24. Very well made video! Lacking a bit on the meat of the issues, but the shopping price comparison really hit home. It’s truly unfortunate that the price disparity was so large, but that is how we are told to “vote with our shopping carts” to get the consumer product results we want. Frustratingly, with all the funds that America spends subsidizing corn, I wonder how our market would shift if – instead of protecting coal – we subsidized local and organic foods. If the products were priced similarly (or even lower!) we might see consumers begin choosing these whole foods on a regular basis. The video might have had more “meaty” take-home content if it had addressed these market issues. Also, the ultimate way to make local/organic products cheaper is to grow and process them yourselves in your own backyard/window sill/community garden!

    ReplyDelete
  25. I enjoyed the style of the video and the comparison of natural/organic products and regular products. The ad in the beginning does a good job portraying an example of green marketing. I feel more could have been said about what makes products better for the environment and how one arrives at decisions when deciding to buy green.

    ReplyDelete
  26. overall i thought the video was good. what bothered me about it was that it seemed to imply that people shouldnt buy green products. Even with the negative things you all brought up green products are by and large better for the environment. as far as production though the it looked great.

    ReplyDelete