Economic Nature-Green Consumerism(http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=hb5GDday7Aw)
Our video subject was based on the topic of economic nature and green consumerism (Infinite Nature Chapter 5, p 87-91). Green consumerism is most commonly visible in our lives when we make an outing to the grocery store. These days within most every chain grocery store you can find a natural/organic section or aisle. We decided to show some insight as to how much going totally “green” in your grocery shopping can cost you compared to similar non-natural/organic products. We not only showed the cost of going green, but we wanted have a discussion as to what buying green really means for individuals as well as the environment.
Overall we felt that non-green products weren’t the problem; over consumption is the main problem. We agree with the point made in lecture that with the growing population and the more wealthy people get, the more we will consume. Consuming more is not necessarily green, even when you using the genuine and disingenuous green products.
The cost of buying green is most certainly on the rise. As mentioned in lecture, people buy green to make them feel less guilty, regardless of the price. In our video we actually go to the grocery store and buy completely organic/natural foods and regular foods. For both the regular and organic products, we mixed name brand and non name brand products to see a close to typical price comparison. People maybe will to pay more to make them feel less guilty and feel as though they are helping save the environment. Although prices are most certainly higher than comparable products they may possibly go down in the future, as since the green revolution is till in its infancy.
There are currently many companies that are apart of the "Go Green movement". As mentioned in lecture, there are different labels like EnergyStar, GreenStar and others that certify green products. The labels "natural" and "organic" are the same. Although "natural" is not a certified term it does have meaning, which is explained in our video. Also, products labeled organic met certain criteria to, for one example produced without the use of pesticides, to obtain the label. With the Go Green movement gaining force, there is a demand for these products. Obviously with a demand, there has to be companies to supply.
Among consumers there is a misconception that buying green products will save our environment. We agree with the point made in lecture that with the growing population and the more wealthy people get, the more we will consume. Consuming more is not necessarily green, even when you using the genuine and disingenuous green products. Although people may feel better about themselves and think they are doing a service to the environment and others, making slightly different shopping decisions won't be the cure all. There has to be a larger scale movement, possibly government policies to regulate.
However, Green products do have an impact, but maybe not as much as they are advertised. One point brought up in our video is, it worth buying five pairs of organic jeans vs. one pair of regular? How much did cost to create organic fibers? A similar advertisement raves that plastic bottled water that uses 15% less plastic. This bottle may less than before but still results in waste. In lecture, the example of the Styrofoam cup vs. ceramic mug is similar.
- Minimize environmental impact:
- Ceramic mug can be recycled, not decompose
- Ceramic mug lasts longer, but has to wash it (water cost)
- Takes more energy to make a mug than a Styrofoam cup
- Have to use ceramic mug a 1000 times to break even.
References Used:
Green Consumerism- Greening All the Way to the Bank (http://sites.google.com/site/richardgosden/green-consumerism)
This article was useful for us to form our opinion that there is little prospect for green consumerism succeeding as a method for solving the environmental crisis.
Buying into the Green Movement
(http://www.nytimes.com/2007/07/01/fashion/01green.html?_r=1&pagewanted=all)
We gained a few very useful quotes and ideas that we used in our video.
USDA Organic- National Organic Plan
(http://www.ams.usda.gov/AMSv1.0/getfile?dDocName=STELDEV3004446&acct=nopgeninfo)
This article from the USDA was imperative to understand what the term organic means and how it is regulated.
Organic Food & Natural Food -what's the difference?
(http://www.naturalhub.com/food_issues_identifying_natural_food.htm)
We found this article to be best to form a definition of what products are considered “natural”.
The (still) high cost of organic food
(http://www.eartheasy.com/article_high_cost_organic_food.htm)
This article brought to our attention the details of why organics still cost more even if there is a demand.
Tuesday, October 6, 2009
Tuesday, September 1, 2009
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)